The Giant Claw has more than one Giant Flaw


For Halloween last month, I reviewed a movie starring Frankenstein’s Monster as a way to tie in with the holiday. I love the holidays, so I challenged myself to do it again for Thanksgiving. Naturally there aren’t any Thanksgiving-themed giant monster movies out of Japan, so I had to get a little more creative. My first thought was Rodan. He’s a big flying monster, sort of like a big bird, like a turkey, the go-to Thanksgiving food.  Knowing I could do better, I went with an American flick from 1957, The Giant Claw. Not only does the titular beast look like a radioactive turkey got humped by a mutant vulture from Hell, but the movie itself is a real turkey! I can hear your booing through the internet, please stop.

We’ll talk about how the movie drove its star to booze, its unflattering peek at the state of gender equality in the 50s, that hilariously unfortunate looking monster, and a whole lot more! Hop aboard a flying battleship and fire up your anti-matter screen, we got a turkey to fry!

Now normally I like to start off by linking to the film’s score, but for the first time, I wasn’t able to find the soundtrack isolated for your listening pleasure! Instead you can hear it during the trailer.  The trailer of course features all the best/worst moments, so if you don’t feel like watching the whole thing, the trailer is a solid Cliffs Notes version.

I'd hate if you guys failed your upcoming giant monster exams.

I’d hate if you guys failed your upcoming giant monster exams.

The music doesn’t do anything stupendous, but it adequately sets the tone, and captures all the bombast you’d expect from a giant monster movie.  Composer Mischa Bakaleinkoff made the understandable decision to go uncredited for Giant Claw, but he got around back in the day. Among other films, he contributed scores for the old Batman serials and a handful of Ray Harryhausen creature features. Speaking of Harryhausen…

"They're not dolls, LEAVE ME ALONE, MOM!"

“I told you they’re not dolls, MOM!”

The stop-motion monster master was originally going to bring Giant Claw’s monster to life, but ultimately that job went to a much smaller outfit from Mexico to cut on costs, and boy did they get what they paid for. Outsourcing the monster creation didn’t stop them from reusing special effects shots from Harryhausen’s Earth vs. the Flying Saucers though. The crumbling Washington monument doubled for New York City skyscraper debris, and if you look closely, you can even catch a split-second of flying saucer.

Stop-motion debris has had more major film appearances that most Hollywood hopefuls.  Sorry.

Which means this stop-motion building debris has had more major film appearances than most Hollywood hopefuls.

But Giant Claw doesn’t just drop a few recycled shots into its cataclysmic climax, oh no. Stock footage permeates the entire production, starting with the bizarre montage and narration that opens the film.  Plenty of giant monster flicks kick off with ominous footage of nuclear bomb tests accompanied by a deep-voiced narrator. When it’s done right, it’s a chilling (though played-out nowadays) way to get us thinking about the possible horrors nuclear testing could unleash, or the impossible vastness of the universe we might share with extraterrestrials, or the folly of man’s hubris.  In The Giant Claw it’s definitely not done right, because it’s a jumble of random images of the earth, then construction equipment, and then finally bomber planes and tanks and stuff.  It is accompanied by narration that says, and I quote:

Through the centuries, science has made man’s lifetime bigger, and the world smaller.

I get what they’re going for, I get the sentiment behind it, but I don’t get why they hired Unfrozen Caveman Lawyer to write it.

I do however, completely get why he decided to follow the composer's lead and go uncredited.

I do however, completely get why he decided to follow the composer’s lead and go uncredited.

Now make sure you read that quote like a folksy Mark Wahlberg, because that’s what the narrator sounds like. It’s great when he talks about “radah” being used to locate bombers, rain clouds, and… homing pigeons. We’re introduced to our leads, an electronics engineer named Mitch MacAfee who also doubles as a test pilot for some reason and beautiful mathematician Sally Caldwell working with him in an arctic research station.  Shortly after their introduction, we have to deal with the batshit narrator again, who’s now dramatically recapping everything we’ve just been shown.  The highlight being when he tells us:

People doing a job, well, efficiently, serious, having fun, doing a job.

He also gives us hilariously detailed updates on the time, date, and weather. The first time he does it is when MacAfee calls in the bird monster as a UFO sighting, so it sort of made sense.  The next five times do not.

If your life was dictated by a clinically insane narrator, you'd be scared too.

If your life was dictated by a clinically insane narrator, you’d be scared too.

Really, the presence of a narrator at all is a bad sign. Nine times out of ten it means there was a major fuck-up and the audience couldn’t quite figure out what was going on, or they needed to pad for time. Considering how straightforward The Giant Claw is, and how much stock footage they stuffed in, it’s gotta be the latter.  The English dub of Rodan has narration too, but it’s the main character telling us about his life, setting up the story, creating atmosphere and cluing us in to what’s going on in town. I’m sure the down and dirty filmmaking reason for it is to cut down on having to match English speech to Japanese-speaking mouths, but it works. It’s hokey, but it moves the story forward, and it doesn’t recap things we’ve already seen.



When MacAfee first spots the monster, it looks like a tumbleweave scooting across the sky. It’s a pretty smart call at this point, making the monster a truly unidentified flying object, as well as hiding the ridiculous creature from us for a bit longer. Though a glob of hairy schmutz zipping by isn’t a huge step up.  This is also when we first hear the beast compared to a battleship. Throughout the film’s brisk running time, each and every character will refer to it being “as big as a battleship” at least twice. Including the narrator. Sometimes they just call it a “flying battleship.”  I lost count, but you could play a very dangerous drinking game by taking a shot every time you hear someone say “battleship.” Even the poster couldn’t fucking help itself:

Were battleships a standard unit of measurement in the 50s? "Oh it's not too far, about 20 battleships from here."

Were battleships a standard unit of measurement in the 50s? “Oh it’s not too far, about 20 battleships from here.”

Anyway, when our engineer/pilot lands, his ground crew tells him nothing showed up on radar. MacAfee and Sally quickly wrap up their work in the arctic, and board a plane to NYC.  On their way home, they find out that a squadron of planes swept the arctic airspace for MacAfee’s invisible monster, and one of the planes never made it back.

It too, wisely chose to go uncredited.

It too, wisely chose to go uncredited.

Our leads are baffled and unnerved by the news, just as an unexplained storm starts tossing their plane around.  MacAfee rushes up front to help the pilot, and the pilot’s acting is so amazingly bad that it forced me to realize the actors playing MacAfee and Sally are doing a pretty bang-up job.  The pilot is knocked out almost instantly, and he starts bleeding from… the turbulence that gently jostled him into unconsciousness? It took me a minute to figure that out, because the blood had the shade and consistency of motor oil.

In The Giant Claw expanded universe fan-fic I'm writing, we find out the pilot was a really fragile robot.

In The Giant Claw expanded universe fan-fic I’m writing, we find out the pilot was actually a really fragile robot.

Our heroes’ plane is now disastrously out of control, and we’re treated to some miniature plane shots. It looks good enough at first, but it starts wobbling and changing speeds hilariously, and I suddenly appreciated the wire work of Toho’s effects teams even more than I did before.

Supposedly Eiji Tsubaraya's plane miniatures were so convincing in his WWII propaganda films, US officials sold the footage to news outlets as actual film of the attack on Pearl Harbor.

Supposedly Eiji Tsubaraya’s plane miniatures were so convincing in his WWII propaganda films, US officials sold the footage to news outlets as actual film of the attack on Pearl Harbor. No joke!

MacAfee and Sally manage to survive the crash somewhere in rural French Canada, but the robot pilot perishes. A friendly French Canadian bumpkin named Pierre (because of course he is) gives them shelter from the storm in his cabin and serves them moonshine. He wanders outside to check on his livestock, but flips a shit over what he sees in the sky. Our heroes rush out to bring him back inside, but Pierre is completely fried with terror. He tells MacAfee and Sally that he saw “the devil in the storm” or La Carcagne, a supposed creature from French Canadian folklore with the face of a wolf, the body of a woman, and gigantic wings.  I’m skipping ahead a little bit, but here’s what The Giant Claw actually looks like:

Which begs the question, what the fuck does Pierre think a woman looks like? Or a wolf, for that matter?

Which begs the question, what the fuck does Pierre think a woman looks like? Or a wolf, for that matter?

It is hilarious. It’s a bird marionette with a tooth-filled beak, bugged-out eyes, an impossibly squat little bod, and the wispiest mohawk. I actually think in the right context, this thing could have been scary. Like, in a David Lynch-style surreal horror film. The hero follows the echoing sound of a baby crying in an abandoned hospital, finally finding a single, covered crib.  The hero throws back the blankets, and sees a split-second shot of this thing convulsing madly and stewing in wet viscera instead of a crying human infant. But instead of surreal horror, we have accidental hilarity as this thing screams through the sky, menacing a feature-less airplane:

Party Tip: Don't do a Google image search for "Eraserhead Baby" at 3 in the morning.

PARTY TIP: Don’t do a Google image search for “Eraserhead Baby” at 3 in the morning.

The cops show up at Pierre’s shanty to investigate the plane crash and help our heroes get home. They quickly give up on interviewing Pierre because he’s “scared stiff.” I have to agree, the actor playing Pierre does a great job. His terrified sobs are convincing; he really sells that Pierre thinks The Giant Claw is an omen of his own imminent death. MacAfee and Sally are given a plane ride home, and that’s when shit gets creepy for completely different reasons.

Okay, maybe not THAT creepy.

Okay, maybe not THAT creepy.

When the scene opens on our heroes flying home, MacAfee is smoking a “thank God we’re not dead” cigarette. Nothing creepy there, just a sign of the times, and fun reminder of what a different era it was. MacAfee looks over at his colleague Sally, she’s fast asleep. So he leans over and starts kissing her passed-out lips.

The-Dale-FaceBut she wakes up and slaps him, or at least politely tells him off, right? NOPE. They make cute small talk and flirt.  Then he steals a newspaper from a sleeping passenger. Then he flushes an adorable puppy out the plane’s toilet. Okay maybe not that last one, but shit, the way things are going it wouldn’t have felt like that much of a stretch, would it? He steals the paper to try and explain his theory that the Giant Claw is attacking in a pattern. He marks the Claw’s attacks on a map, making an almost straight line, but instead of connecting the dots directly, he does it with a huge looping spiral. I was happy to see Sally agree with me that that theory looks like crazy bullshit.  Since we’re finding out MacAfee is kind of a shitbox, he pouts when Sally doesn’t agree with him. He apologizes for acting like a big shitty baby, and goes in for another kiss, and this time she’s up for it.


The movie thankfully takes our mind off the fact that Sally has the worst taste in men ever by finally showing us the monster, in all its stupid glory.  Our folksy Mark Wahlberg narrator gives us another detailed update on the time, date and weather as pilots call in the creature. This time they finally call it a giant bird. The Giant Claw, a huge mutant chicken, gets called a battleship more often than it gets called a bird. The beast destroys the (again featureless) plane, with the brave pilots parachuting just in time.  Just in time to get eaten by the Giant Claw!

They even make a little crunch noise when the Claw chomps down on them!

They even make a little crunch noise when the Claw chomps down on them!

They dangled actors in parachutes in front of a screen playing the monster footage, and with some swift editing it all comes together really well. It’s not perfect, but I can’t imagine it looking any better with miniatures or stop motion.  Especially on this budget.

There's no way they could afford more than one color. This is also my first time ever seeing blue army men. Who knew?

There’s no way they could afford more than one color. This is also my first time ever seeing blue army men. Who knew?

MacAfee and Sally are taken in to a high-ranking general’s office to discuss how to handle the monstrous bird. They decide to use recordings from weather balloons to track the creature’s whereabouts, and we get to see a series of ridiculous monster selfies:



Over the radio (more slick cost-cutting!) the general has a group of fighter jets engage the evil turkey.  The pilots are quippy as hell, with one declaring “I’ll never call my mother-in-law an old crow again!”  The whole movie is like that, with MacAfee spewing the most one-liners. The delivery is so dry I can’t tell if it’s intended to be funny, or if it’s just a matter of old idioms sounding sarcastic to a modern ear. Combining the dry one-liners with the awesomely shitty monster almost makes it seem like The Giant Claw is a giant farce, but it’s lacking the self-aware wit to push it into intentional comedy territory. It’s not meta enough be a Young Frankenstein or a Cabin in the Woods. Giant Claw came out early in the atomic monster wave, and there’s some other evidence that points to it being a genuine attempt at nuclear horror that we’ll talk about later.

And it looks like whoever made this fan-art takes the movie pretty seriously too.

And it looks like whoever made this fan-art takes the movie pretty seriously too.

The Giant Claw of course makes short work of the fighter jets, revealing that conventional weaponry can’t even touch it.  The nuclear option is authorized almost immediately and without any fuss, which seems really strange compared to so many other kaiju and atomic monster films.

"Eh, what's the big deal?" -The Giant Claw creative team

“Eh, what’s the big deal?” -The Giant Claw screenwriters

Rather than showing us what would happen if the bird was blasted with a bomb, we’re escorted into a classroom so a scientist can tell us a bunch of pseudo-science explaining the monster. Some movies can do this well, Gojira being possibly the best example. In Gojira they admit that they don’t have any definite answers, and are basing their presentation on what little information they do have. It actually makes the monster seem even stranger and more mysterious.  The Giant Claw of course is no Gojira, so instead of a scientist presenting us with his findings, we get a guy telling us about anti-matter, and that the monster surely projects an anti-matter screen that protects it from our weapons.  The monster in turn attacks us by opening the screen just enough for his beak and claws to pass through. Also, it’s definitely a space alien from an “anti-matter galaxy.”


The scientist never explains how or why he came to those conclusions. The closest we get is when he shows us how “expensive” it was to try to analyze a feather from the monster they found. He points to a pile of wrecked equipment, so apparently trying to take readings on the feather blew up their instruments? Apparently all this irrefutable evidence is enough to convince the armed forces to not even attempt nuking the beast, and the monster sets off on a worldwide rampage.

And just like the video game, The Giant Claw's rampage is a couple minutes' worth of fun.

And just like the video game, The Giant Claw’s rampage is a couple minutes’ worth of fun.

We get a quick, stock footage filled montage of what the narrator helpfully describes as “Panic, terrah, and horrah.” This is actually pretty cool: in it’s own budget-conscious way, Giant Claw delivers on the global terror that so many atom-age monster movie trailers promise. Curfews are enacted and the military steps in to transport supplies to citizens. We even find out that the nations of the world are working together to try and stop the Giant Claw. Despite what the radio declares a “fantastic orgy of destruction, “Sally visits MacAfee in his apartment. They seem weirdly cheerful for living in a world terrorized by a gigantic man-eating space bird. Giant monster throwing humanity into chaos:


Anyway, Sally rolls up because she’s convinced The Giant Claw is on Earth to build a nest and raise what would have surely been hilarious-looking babies. She’s sure of her theory because she saw a giant footprint outside of Pierre’s cabin. I’m usually not a nitpicky viewer, especially when it comes to schlocky B-movies, but come on. This is a gigantic prehistoric space-bird from a bizarro universe that can fucking manipulate anti-matter: it could be here for a trillion different reasons, including no reason at all! I like the nest route, it gives us one of the more fun sequences in the movie, and it’s a tried-and-true monster movie trope, but you could have led into it with something more substantial than “I saw a footprint one time.”

A sneak peek into the writer's room for The Giant Claw.

A sneak peek into the writer’s room for The Giant Claw.

So MacAfee and Sally high-tail it back to French Canada, which of course, is ze best Canada. They track down The Giant Claw’s nest, complete with gigantic chicken eggs. The Giant Claw is still adding trees to its nest, and it’s actually some pretty impressive puppetry. The monster sometimes looks decent in profile (sometimes) but is still a scream for all the wrong reasons when you view it head on.  MacAfee starts blasting eggs, which satisfyingly spray goo on impact. Sally tells an incredulous MacAfee “I’m from Montana!” as she grabs a rifle and starts bulls-eyeing huevos.

Shockingly, neither MacAfee nor Sally  bother to make a lame omelette joke. Happy to pick up the slack.

Shockingly, neither MacAfee nor Sally bother to make a lame omelette joke. Happy to pick up the slack.

I didn’t quite get what happened next.  I think the bird started dropping trees on our heroes in retaliation for her shattered eggs? And then something happens to Pierre, which makes him a dead guy. I really am not sure what though.  Too much wine and cheese? Complications from a mime-related injury?

Baguette overdose?

Baguette overdose?

MacAfee and Sally decide it’s time to get the hell out of French Canada and hop into their car. They keep their lights off to avoid attracting the Giant Claw, but the shitty youths drunk driving in a hot-rod behind them don’t give a hoot! They are awesome, hanging off the sides of the zooming little car, swinging beer cans, flashing their lights and yelling at our cautious heroes before finally passing them and continuing their joyride. This being a “horror” film, The Giant Claw goes into full Jason Vorhees mode to punish the reveling teenagers for being young, irresponsible, and impetuous.

No word yet on what movie monsters think of tweens though.

No word yet on what movie monsters think of tweens though.

Before the Claw even has a chance to do anything, two of the kids bail while the car’s still pushing 90. The Claw swoops down for the remaining teens and carries them up into the sky, hot-rod and all. The car doesn’t explode in its grasp, but the monster has to let go and have the car drop a bit for the explosion to go off.  The same thing happens whenever the Claw bites into an airplane.  This is of course due to lackluster special effects, but for some reason, my stupid brain decided to meet the The Giant Claw halfway. What if this was intentional? What if the monster is purposely dropping vehicles onto its invisible anti-matter screen to blow them up? The very credible scientist from earlier in the film tells us that the Claw absorbs energy from what it destroys through osmosis, so maybe the anti-matter screen does all the absorbing?

Brain what are you doing, this movie BLLLRRRGHGH

Brain what are you doing, this movie BLLLRRRGHGH

Our heroes make it back to NYC, and find out that mesic atoms will break through the bird’s forcefield because reasons.  While MacAfee, Sally and Dr. Exposition work on making a mesic atom launcher, the Giant Claw finally goes apeshit on New York, and we get the movie’s remaining monster money shots. The Claw gives King Kong a nod by perching atop the Empire State Building:


Blazes a new trail by taking a bite out of the UN Building (breaking it’s neck in the process?):

giant claw And later it haphazardly derps into a random skyscraper, showering the panicked pedestrians with debris. And when your monster looks so awesomely bad, it’s a joy to behold. Now that’s not me just being a cynical filmgoer jaded by modern multi-billion dollar special effects; opening day audiences found The Giant Claw to be a riot too. Star Jeff Morrow first saw the movie in his hometown, but hearing the audience roar with laughter every time the monster popped up, he left early to go home and drink.

Relevant MS Paint image

Relevant MS Paint image. Also words to live by.

On one hand I absolutely get where he’s coming from. The Giant Claw was not the next Gojira or the next Them! and is by all rights a laughable train wreck of a movie. But it’s important that it’s a laughable train wreck. It’s fun to watch, maybe for the wrong reasons, but who cares? I always prefer movies that are hilarious flops to movies that are play-it-safe, forgettable, middle-of-the-road affairs. Even with its many, many problems, Troll 2 is a million times better than, say, a movie like SWAT. Troll 2 is a ridiculous mess, but I remember it fondly, I have great memories of watching it with my friends, and it was a ton of fun speculating what happened behind the scenes (and then finding out by watching Best Worst Movie). SWAT does everything competently, takes no chances, never falls flat on its face, and I think I fell asleep during it.  Or at least wanted to.

Just looking at the box for SWAT somehow makes me sleepy and annoyed at the same time.

Just looking at the box somehow makes me sleepy and irritated at the same time.

Even with all its problems, The Giant Claw doesn’t quite reach the divine lunacy of movies like Troll 2, The Room, or Plan 9 From Outer Space. It’s just too damn coherent! That said, The Giant Claw earns its Z-movie status and delivers battleship-sized laughs (and cringes) throughout. Happy (early) Thanksgiving, ya turkeys.


Some content on this page was disabled on July 5, 2022 as a result of a DMCA takedown notice from Martin McNeil. You can learn more about the DMCA here:

11 thoughts on “The Giant Claw has more than one Giant Flaw

  1. Oh, man, I just watched this. I found it at a Michael’s, of all places, as part of a bargain-priced four-movie set alongside Twenty Million Miles to Earth, It Came from Beneath the Sea, and Mothra. It has instantly become my new favorite bad monster movie.

  2. The Giant Claw is one of my favorite Giant Monsters when I was a kid! I didn’t care how stupid it looked but I am doing a stop motion film called Godzilla vs the Giant Claw. People are saying “Is the claw going to have his anti matter shield?” Yes but he turns it off when he wants to fight or eat. So I don’t know if I can put a link to part 1 of my film and some photos but will try here.

  3. I want to keep up the concept of the Giant Claw but every time I watch the movies I see some errors in the logic of the Giant Claw of which there are a lot of errors in that movie. One of them is that when he attacks or wants to eat to adsorb energy he has to turn off his anti-matter shield and of course when he wants to attack. I thought this would have been a better plot device than that stupid Macafee trying to destroy the birds anti’matter shield. When the Giant Claw was attacking the jets in the attack I figured the jets should have been able get him, he would have been vulnerable. The fact that he was attacking buildings and destroying them he had to turn his shield off. There are plot points in the movie that don’t make sense in where they should have been able to get the Claw. In my film The Claw looks at Godzilla as a meal to absorb his energy and he has to turn his shield off. That’s the way that I’m doing the film, it has the same concept, I am just looking at the flaws to make the film more logical. He does turn the shield on, but only in defense. As I talk right now I am still doing the film and hoping to finish it by the time I go to G-Fest this year. Here is a link to another film I did showing a famous Flying Monster.

    • I think a monster like the Giant Claw is ripe for reinterpretation.

      I’m loving that stop-motion Rodan and Hedorah! Super cool to see the Amazing Colossal Man/Beast get some love too! I really get a kick out of how you mix American and Japanese monsters.

  4. Thank you But you know what, I wanted to shoot more in black and white, I wanted to shoot the whole fight scene in black and white. But Black and white is it’s ow art form, you have to shoot it just right to make it look good. I still want to shoot some animation scenes with the Giant Claw in Black and white. Here is a link to a anime character, the very first anime character to be brought to America. I wanted to shoot the character in Black and white, just for the tradition. Here is a little link to the opening title.

  5. I am an unrepentant fan of the Giant Claw, though probably not for the reasons most others might be. Sure, the special effects are laughable, but even Star Trek and Doctor Who had some cringeworthy FX moments. The actual plot is admittedly genuinely weak and the characters one dimensional and not very redeeming to modern eyes. The concept, however, is straight-up cosmic horror, in the tradition of H. P. Lovecraft (also noted for his one dimensional characters and multi-dimensional monsters). That it ties into legend and superstition is again right out of his playbook. The universe of the Giant Claw is one where a single giant space bird can threaten all of humanity who, when it regards them at all, thinks of them as light snacks. The overall message is mankind is small and pathetic compared to what’s out there, not to mention ignorant of the dangers of other entities’ mere presence. Science just managed to pull their bacon out of the fire , but what of next time?

    I guess Kaiju movies are kind of a cosmic horror adjacent genre, but that’s what really stood out about this film to me…and I’d love to see a remake with a decent budget that expanded on those strengths. I doubt we ever will, or if we do they’ll intentionally try to play it all for laughs, but hope springs eternal…

    • Keith, I’m convinced a terrifying take on The Giant Claw is doable. The snarky answer is that it exists and is called Rodan, but I get what you mean with the cosmic horror, Lovecraftian angle. The Giant Claw is so goddamn weird that it feels more aligned with those tentacled, deep-space terrors than Godzilla and his atomic brethren.

      Kaiju and cosmic horror hit a few of the same notes, and that’s always fascinated me. When kaiju do horror though, they generally zero in on blaming humans–horror kaiju are almost always the result of nuclear or genetic testing, pollution run amok, or us just otherwise sticking our noses where they damn well should never have been. Cosmic horrors on the other hand are just OUT THERE whether we did anything bad or not. It’s a particularly unnerving stripe of existential dread, and a big part of what draws me to the genre. Sure enough, the Giant Claw is just fucking THERE, and that’s creepy as hell.

      I think somebody could definitely retool GC into a full-on cosmic horror, but at that point you’d probably have a whole new beast… which wouldn’t be a bad thing either! I don’t think it’s particularly Lovecraftian, but have you seen Q: The Winged Serpent? It’s about a flying beast (once thought to be a myth) terrorizing modern NYC! Might scratch that Giant Claw reboot itch!

      Thanks for reading, and thanks for sharing your take on this mohawked miscreant!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s